Practice Areas

Blog

Medical Malpractice

view all

Firm News

Newport News Police Official Convicted of Drunken Driving

Three-Car Accident Kills One Person and Injures Four Others

Three High School Students Killed in a Car Crash in Virginia Beach

Young Volunteer Firefighter Killed in Crash

Former Virginia Tech Quarterback Found Guilty of DUI

Four Deaths on Virginia 151 Prompted Change

Fossella Found Guilty of Misdemeanor Charges of DUI in Virginia

Study Reveals 13% of Seniors Report Mistreatment

Grant Helps the Elderly Avoid Nursing Homes

Driver Convicted of DUI Death Arrested Again on DUI Charge

View All

Firm Library

Nursing Home Abuse

More Info

Personal Injury and Automobile Accidents

More Info

Medical Malpractice

More Info

DUI, Traffic and Criminal Law Defense

More Info

Divorce

More Info

General

More Info

Weisberg Law Blog

Weisberg Law Blog
Blog Category:

Medical Malpractice

    2/29/2008
    Brian
    Comments (0)

    Supreme Court Grants Immunity for FDA Approved Medical Devices

    In a landmark decision this week, the Supreme Court of the United States granted tort immunity to manufacturers of medical devices that have recieved FDA pre-market approval.

    In Riegal v. Medtronic, the plaintiff had filed a lawsuit after a Medtronic catheter ruptured in Mr. Riegal's coronary artery during a heart surgery.  Even though the catheter's labeling specifically warns against use for patients with diffuse or calcified stenoses, the doctor choose to use it in Mr. Riegal's heavily calcified artery.  As the heart surgeon was inflating the catheter, it ruptured, leaving Mr. Riegal on life support and requiring emergency coronary bypass surgery.

    The catheter had recieved FDA pre-market approval.  Any medical device must undergo extensive screening by the FDA before it can be sold (hence the name "pre-market approval").  This screening includes an average of 1,200 hours of FDA review per application to ensure that each device has a "reasonable assurance" of the device's "safety and effectiveness," as weighed against hte probable risk of injury or illness resulting from use.

    The result of this decision is to make it virtually impossible to sue manufacturers of medical devices - like pacemakers or catheters - as long as they have been pre-approved by the FDA.  While the FDA does a great job in screening out medical devices not ready for the mass market, their screening process does not warrant giving blanket immunity to the makers of medical devices. 

    Even scarier?  The Supreme Court will hear a case next term regarding the exact same issue - but with prescription drugs.  This could be the end of manufacturer liability in the medical industry.

    Read More about "Supreme Court Grants Immunity for FDA Approved Medical Devices"


    Labels:

Comments

There are no comments.

Post a comment

Post a Comment to "Supreme Court Grants Immunity for FDA Approved Medical Devices"

To reply to this message, enter your reply in the box labeled "Message", enter your username and password, and hit "Post Message."

Username:

Password:

Register for an account

Message:

Ask an AttorneyAsk an Attorney
Free Consultation

Name:

Phone:

Email:

Tell us more:


Weisberg & Zaleski, P.C.
112 College Place
Norfolk, VA 23510

Toll Free: (800) 690-0235
Phone: (757) 622-7740
Fax: (757) 533-9223

Map / Directions

FAQs

Personal Injury and Automobile Accidents

Medical Malpractice

DUI, Traffic and Criminal Law Defense

Business Litigation

Divorce

View All